Log in

No account? Create an account
Why oh, why? - Straight From the Source [entries|archive|friends|userinfo]
Ask JKR a Question

[ website | Jo Rowling's Website ]
[ userinfo | livejournal userinfo ]
[ archive | journal archive ]

Why oh, why? [Sep. 25th, 2005|07:15 pm]
Ask JKR a Question


[mood |curiouscurious]
[music |Nightwish - Walking in the Air]

I just read half-blood prince and was just wondering what the heck happened? I've been depressed the whole day because it left so bad taste in my mouth...
So why there weren't any plot in the book but just some weird teenage romance stuff? I'm actually kind of shamed now to have said everybody how I love Harry Potter, because now... well I don't think I can force myself to read the up-coming ones if their going to be as stupid as this. I actually had to close my eyes, like with some very bad fanfiction, in some point because the text was just so lame and absurd and 'bold and beautiful' like.

So what was this all about? Did you dry up of ideas? Wanted to please the teenage fans? Wan't to please the movie studios?

And that love part... please... what was that? I saw Harry face voldemort with ten carebears... I though you had some serious point behind your writing but I guess I was wrong (not that the power of love is bad thing... it's just so cliche to be said in that form).

[User Picture]From: masterofmystery
2005-09-25 11:45 pm (UTC)
They are teenagers, last time I checked they were allowed to be in love and stuff. Besides, Jo already answered all this stuff in her interview with Mugglenet back in July. ;)
(Reply) (Thread)